**This property was impacted by *Hurricane Irma* and Hurricane Maria in September 2017 and is closed for repairs through late 2018. We will update our review as soon as we have more information.** On paper, Peter Island Resort & Spa has a lot to like. It's set on a private island, with a water-view pool, two-oceanside restaurants, and five private beaches (including the exclusive Honeymoon Beach, which is only available to a single couple each day, is a truly romantic highlight). However, the 53 homey rooms are underwhelming for a hotel of this caliber, despite a variable range of features that can include whirlpool tubs, ocean-view balconies, and butlers. Unfortunately, things feel as worn and dated throughout the entire resort, which keeps it from living up to its luxury claims. There's no direct competition in the area, though Tortola's Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina, Autograph Collection has many of the same amenities for a fraction of the price.
**This property was impacted by *Hurricane Irma* and Hurricane Maria in September 2017 and is closed for repairs through late 2018. We will update our review as soon as we have more information.** On paper, Peter Island Resort & Spa has a lot to like. It's set on a private island, with a water-view pool, two-oceanside restaurants, and five private beaches (including the exclusive Honeymoon Beach, which is only available to a single couple each day, is a truly romantic highlight). However, the 53 homey rooms are underwhelming for a hotel of this caliber, despite a variable range of features that can include whirlpool tubs, ocean-view balconies, and butlers. Unfortunately, things feel as worn and dated throughout the entire resort, which keeps it from living up to its luxury claims. There's no direct competition in the area, though Tortola's Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina, Autograph Collection has many of the same amenities for a fraction of the price.