Though you would never suspect it from the outside, the four-pearl Borgo Don Chisciotte is a grand property with impressive amenities, including a sleek and well-outfitted spa. Its 132 rooms are elegant and have hardwood floors and rain showers -- some also come with whirlpool tubs. The barren outside lacks the landscaping befitting of a resort, so the large outdoor pool loses some of its luxury in the daytime. Travelers not looking for a spa, and who want something that looks a little chicer, might prefer the nearby Pietre Nere Resort.

This upper-middle-range, modern boutique property is a rarity in this part of Sicily where older hotels are the norm. The stylish rooms are decorated in a minimalist fashion (some might call it spartan). Amenities include a large pool with a hot tub and a restaurant that serves a gourmet take on Sicilian dishes. While the location is a bit remote, it’s a good base for exploring the southeastern part of the island. The resort is a popular spot for weddings, which can sometimes get noisy late at night.