Sol Cayo Guillermo is a traditional mid-range all-inclusive resort that’s much smaller and more intimate than most sprawling Cayo Coco properties. Its 268 bungalow-style rooms are simple but comfortable and clean with furnished patios and garden or sea views. But the beach is the biggest highlight here -- a long, wide stretch of white sand and aqua water, although it can get windy (a bonus for kite surfers). Guests also appreciate the nightly entertainment, intimate atmosphere, and the casual, chilled out nature of this place. Overall, Sol Cayo Guillermo is dated and there’s nothing fancy going on here (a la carte restaurants are even devoid of dress codes), but it’s this laid-back simplicity guests appreciate. Another similar property to consider could be the Sercotel Club Cayo Guillermo.

With 324 guest rooms, the three-pearl Sercotel Club Cayo Guillermo is smaller than other sprawling all-inclusives in the Jardines del Rey chain, so the vibe here is much more intimate. The main, original area of the hotel is family-friendly -- and shows its age -- while the newer Club Prestige section feels like its own mini-resort, catering to adults only with an exclusive feel. The resort's layout requires minimal walking, grounds are beautifully maintained, and there's a gorgeous beach, but Sercotel is far from perfect, so luxury seekers will be disappointed. Some past guests complain of poor maintenance in rooms, while others seem satisfied. All units come with patios or balconies, AC, mini-fridges, and safes, but some have old tube TVs, and there's no in-room Wi-Fi. Travelers looking for a larger, more modern property could try Melia Jardines del Rey.