Despite its British owners, the two-pearl ReefView Apartments might just be among the most authentic places to stay in Antigua. Case in point: the property's discreet location in a quiet local neighborhood near the rainforest and a wild beach. The three hand-built cottages have full kitchens, private patios, and eclectic decor that feels homey, but can look dated. Plumbing and minor maintenance issues aren't unheard of, but for self-sufficient travelers wanting a rustic, local experience, this place is the ticket. The owners are also always available for travel tips and tour booking. For similar (or moderately lower) rates, a prettier beach, and equally Caribbean ambiance, the Catamaran Hotel is about 25 minutes down the road.